Here in Japan I've never been asked "Anata no karate ryuha wa dore desu ka?" ("Which karate style do you do?") Hey! Just like you, I am a person! I'm André Bertel, not a style..._______
Amusingly enough, one of the biggest questions 'outside of Japan' amongst karateka, is exactly that... "What style do you practice?" Ironically, here in Nippon, whilst politics obviously still exist, there is just karate-do, competition and traditional. The biggest divisions are not style, but rather the manners/main objectives of training.
_______
The three main 'manners of training' are: (1) Full-contact karate - get in the ring for a KO (such as Kyokushin, Seidokaikan and others); (2) Sports karate (focused on WKF rules competition karate) - look pretty doing kata and tag to score points in kumite; and (3) Budo/Bujutsu karate, which is focused on 'ippon technique', that is karate (kihon, kata and kumite) with a 'single killing blow' as the prime objective -"Continued life or death in an instant."_______
So when someone says they practice Uechi-ryu, Wado-ryu, Shorin-ryu, Seido, Goju-ryu, Shito-ryu, Shukokai, Kyokushinkai, Ryuei-ryu, Shotokan etc.., it really doesn't say much. The real issue is how they practice, and what they sincerely practice for. Do they train for full-contact fighting, sports karate, or for application in the real world. One may argue that they train for a combination of these, however, this is impossible, if a reliable level expertise is desired in any of these fields.
_______
This is the reason why I accept, and respect, all styles of karate, and all martial arts. Regardless of style, some people are prize fighters, some are sports players and some are lethal weapons. Style does not establish this. To me, all that matters is 'what people train for'. The best karateka in the world are one's who train for reality, the single finishing blow, because regardless of style, they are the people who are keeping real tradition of karate alive.
© André Bertel, Japan (2009).
No comments:
Post a Comment